MFGG - Mario Fan Games Galaxy

MYSMB1

By: metroidmetroid
This is my first submission to mfgg the engine was by hello not me have fun!

Completion: Demo	Genre: Adventure
Franchise: Mario

Update History


No History

Add submission to your favorites

Report This Submission

	Created:	Jun 17 2008, 5:10 PM
	Updated:	Never
	File Size:	2.74MB
	Views:	13484
	Downloads:	3228
	Plays:	0
	Favorites:	0
Download!

Reviews

Author	Summary	Score
CCTV	It's really bad, from pixel perfect jumps, to graphics that vary in quality. This deserves a low score... 2/10...	2 / 10
SMBXfan	An ordinary Hello clone that does not deserve your time.	2 / 10
TheTwelfthRocket	MYSMB1? More like MY1-1. I can't believe how bad you can mess up a first submission. Yes, there is such thing as bad first games, but seriously. NEVER USE HELLO'S SMB1 ENGINE. IT'S BAD. NEVER EVER USE IT.	1 / 10
HyperLuigi64	"Numbers never lie." as Sheldon may say, but if this was ever to be scored higher then a 2, they certainly would.	2 / 10
Ryan Silberman	Mario must be disappointed. He's been going through 3 levels that are the same. He shouldn't take much more of that	2 / 10
the real wart	A Hello engine edit to make it look like the classic SMB, but fails to deliver what we have been hoping for to make it classic like original levels. Next time, just put in your own ideas and not just use the same damn level 3 times.	1 / 10
Vertette	Try to be original please.	2 / 10
Mr. Yoshbert	MYSMB1 is just a short, bland, and glitchy edit of Hello's engine. At least if it uses another person's engine, edit it the RIGHT way.	2 / 10
Torkirby	This is a easy, short, glitchy game that uses Hello's SMB1 Engine. Simply just a lousy edit from the engine.	2 / 10
Average Score		1.8 / 10

Add Review

Comments

	~~jak~~ Aug 17 2008, 8:18 PM
wow,another game!


	~~The Grand Star~~ Aug 17 2008, 11:22 PM
Hey I have a question... how do you assign different music to different levels?


	~~DoctorWario~~ Aug 18 2008, 1:05 AM
Change some of the sounds, they need be 8-bit and can you make it freeze for a while when you get the powerup??? anyways, nice gam


	metroidmetroid Aug 18 2008, 1:41 AM
Quote (DoctorWario on Aug 18 2008, 1:05 AM) Change some of the sounds, they need be 8-bit and can you make it freeze for a while when you get the powerup??? anyways, nice gam i dont have the engine any more because my computer crashed


	metroidmetroid Aug 18 2008, 1:43 AM
Quote (The Grand Star on Aug 17 2008, 11:22 PM) Hey I have a question... how do you assign different music to different levels? i dont remember and i cant check because my computer crashed


	Grant Aug 18 2008, 4:43 AM
plays ...Seriously? The first 3 out of 4 levels are all edits of the same level! (And that level is included in the engine itself!) Not only that, but the only original one - the 4th - is pretty much nothing but a giant line of enemies, a huge pit or so, and an invisible floor, and it also lacks a boss even though it's a castle. And this with a pre-made engine? How many minutes did it take to make this...?


	metroidmetroid Aug 18 2008, 2:15 PM
Quote (Grant on Aug 18 2008, 4:43 AM) plays ...Seriously? The first 3 out of 4 levels are all edits of the same level! (And that level is included in the engine itself!) Not only that, but the only original one - the 4th - is pretty much nothing but a giant line of enemies, a huge pit or so, and an invisible floor, and it also lacks a boss even though it's a castle. And this with a pre-made engine? How many minutes did it take to make this...? it took days! and the levels are not edits! level 1 is form the engine but the other levels are ones that i made!


	Grant Aug 18 2008, 9:34 PM
Quote (metroidmetroid on Aug 18 2008, 10:15 AM) it took days! and the levels are not edits! level 1 is form the engine but the other levels are ones that i made! It is really easy to tell that the levels are edits. They have the exact same features in some places, like the up-and-down stairs with the hole in between near the end, and the arrangement of blocks and pipes after that (appeared in all 3 non-castle levels in the game), the block setup right near the beginning (appeared in all 3 levels), and that arrangement of 4 blocks near the middle that in the original game came shortly after the Starman block. If I felt like it, I could compare screenshots of the levels side by side to prove my claims. But again, most players paying attention to the level design will notice this quickly anyway.


	metroidmetroid Aug 18 2008, 10:03 PM
Quote (Grant on Aug 18 2008, 9:34 PM) It is really easy to tell that the levels are edits. They have the exact same features in some places, like the up-and-down stairs with the hole in between near the end, and the arrangement of blocks and pipes after that (appeared in all 3 non-castle levels in the game), the block setup right near the beginning (appeared in all 3 levels), and that arrangement of 4 blocks near the middle that in the original game came shortly after the Starman block. If I felt like it, I could compare screenshots of the levels side by side to prove my claims. But again, most players paying attention to the level design will notice this quickly anyway. some of level 1-1 is an edit but not 1-2 1-3 1-4


	Grant Aug 18 2008, 10:07 PM
Your denial is only digging you in deeper. (By the way, I know that 1-4 isn't an edit. I never said it was.) Plus I'm not even the only one who says the first 3 are edits. See Torkirby's review of the game.


	smbmaster99 Aug 20 2008, 12:17 AM
i like this game a lot, dispite some of the glitches. after all, it IS your 1st submission & i think you deserve at least SOME credit & not criticisms. this is a good fangame & i recomend everyone play @ least once. i hope it's done soon! Edit: hey i'm just wondering, where can you find Hello's smb1 engine? i know it must be glitchy, but i'll try most things @ least once


	Grant Aug 20 2008, 9:44 PM
Quote (smbmaster99 on Aug 19 2008, 8:17 PM) after all, it IS your 1st submission & i think you deserve at least SOME credit & not criticisms. Nope, you're wrong about the "criticisms". When someone is inexperienced at making fangames, criticism is extremely important - even vital - in order for them to improve. If one just uncritically praises a fangame whether it deserves it in its own right or not, why would the fangame's creator bother to try very much to get better?


	metroidmetroid Aug 21 2008, 12:49 AM
hey smbmaster99 the engine its here at mfgg.net you go to how-tos


	metroidmetroid Aug 21 2008, 12:52 AM
Quote (smbmaster99 on Aug 20 2008, 12:17 AM) i like this game a lot, dispite some of the glitches. after all, it IS your 1st submission & i think you deserve at least SOME credit & not criticisms. this is a good fangame & i recomend everyone play @ least once. i hope it's done soon! Edit: hey i'm just wondering, where can you find Hello's smb1 engine? i know it must be glitchy, but i'll try most things @ least once i cant finish it my comupter crashed


	smbmaster99 Aug 21 2008, 11:39 AM
@Grant-fine. whatever. I'm not gonna argue. @metroidmetroid-thanks & sorry to hear your computer crashed Edit:oh yeah, do you remember how to make levels end? the flag in the engine don't work. plz don't be angry at me if ya can't remember.


	smbmaster99 Aug 21 2008, 2:53 PM
ALRIGHT. i finally found out how to end levels. all i need to know is how to change music for levels. would you by any chance remember how that works?


	metroidmetroid Aug 21 2008, 4:58 PM
Quote (smbmaster99 on Aug 21 2008, 2:53 PM) ALRIGHT. i finally found out how to end levels. all i need to know is how to change music for levels. would you by any chance remember how that works? no i dont


	Yrr Aug 23 2008, 3:05 PM
I can't believe how you expect us to believe that the first three levels are not edits, all you did was move/delete a few things and make it underground. Plus this game is short, bland and unoriginal.


	metroidmetroid Aug 23 2008, 4:52 PM
Quote (thingy on Aug 23 2008, 11:05 AM) I can't believe how you expect us to believe that the first three levels are not edits, all you did was move/delete a few things and make it underground. Plus this game is short, bland and unoriginal. i was not as good as im now


	im4everkool Aug 23 2008, 10:29 PM
The first three levels are edits. Do not argue and lie and say they are original because they are not so just quit it. This game is too short, and not original. Also, you can't improve at Game maker if all you do is arrange levels using a premade engine thats glitchy. (No offense Hello.)


	the real wart Aug 27 2008, 8:07 PM
Holy crap, every level is the same design except for the castle level which is poorly made. Looks like you need a review from me to shapen up your gaming attitude.


	mariofan994 Sep 21 2008, 10:17 PM
Though the first 3 are just tile edits, the idea of an 8-bit desert stage was priceless. That and the fact that the castle is impossible are my only problems with this game along with a glitch or two.


	Soilworker Nov 6 2008, 8:10 PM
Wow what a horrible game. Like the levels are the same, you copied that level the engine had and just editted it each time. There's so many area repeats it's not funny.


	metroidmetroid Nov 10 2008, 10:57 PM
Quote (Soilworker on Nov 6 2008, 4:10 PM) Wow what a horrible game. Like the levels are the same, you copied that level the engine had and just editted it each time. There's so many area repeats it's not funny. i was not as good as i am now


	Ryan Silberman Feb 14 2010, 2:01 AM
Worst SMB revamp of all time.


	crazymario64 Apr 2 2010, 12:05 AM
Found bugs and things needed: 1.Mario needs to be able to crouch. 2.If a mushroom is stuck between 2 blocks it will float down and float slowly until its out of the way 3.The castle needs less lava,Goombas and smaller fire blocks 4.If I hit for example a goomba in the desert it wall look like a regular goomba So this needs editing


	metroidmetroid Apr 17 2010, 2:26 AM
Quote (SMBMM on Feb 13 2010, 10:01 PM) Worst SMB revamp of all time. If you hate it so bad then way did you waste your time commenting?


	metroidmetroid Apr 17 2010, 2:26 AM
Quote (crazymario64 on Apr 1 2010, 8:05 PM) Found bugs and things needed: 1.Mario needs to be able to crouch. 2.If a mushroom is stuck between 2 blocks it will float down and float slowly until its out of the way 3.The castle needs less lava,Goombas and smaller fire blocks 4.If I hit for example a goomba in the desert it wall look like a regular goomba My comp crashed so i can't sorry So this needs editing


	metroidmetroid Apr 17 2010, 2:28 AM
Quote (smbmaster99 on Aug 21 2008, 10:53 AM) ALRIGHT. i finally found out how to end levels. all i need to know is how to change music for levels. would you by any chance remember how that works? Hey i know it's been along time since you posted this but all you do is create another object and put the music you want and loop it


	Double Agent Luigifan Apr 24 2012, 6:40 PM
Quote (metroidmetroid on Apr 16 2010, 10:28 PM) All you do is create another object and put the music you want and loop it NO. You actually put in the creation code of the room this: sound_loop(yoursound); Put that because if you don't, you'd have to make a object for every leve to change the music assuming every level has a different song. Quote (metroidmetroid on Apr 16 2010, 10:26 PM) If you hate it so bad then way did you waste your time commenting? Probably because he wants to express his opinion on this? Sure it's not constructive critisisumm, but hey, at least it's something. Like I said on PJ's sprites, but I think Ridge Koopa said it before me: The commenting system is for expressing your opinion. What are we supposed to say? "Oh well it's awesome!"but truly think it's not great? So don't EVER say that again. Metriodmetriod, why did you quote crazymario64's comment for no reason? Quote (metroidmetroid on Aug 23 2008, 12:52 PM) i was not as good as im now DON'T EVER use that as an exuse. Just read what Grant said. If you don't want to, READ THIS. Even if you are better now, you should at least fix the glitches that the engine had before. Plus, this is just another sprite swap of the Hello Engine SMB1(At least I think, because I haven't played this game in a long time.) First of all, the engine is really slippery, and glitchy overall. If a mushroom gets stuck between two solids it floats down, most glitches from the Hello Engine SMB1 persists. And also, you'd become more experienced if you coded your own engine, since you can't learn that way. Please, if you're gonna keep using engines, please stop using the Hello Engigne SMB1. It's very glitchy. Use something like Darkyoshi's Mario engine. Also, stop dening that the levels aren't edits. They are very similar. The only exepction is the castle level, which is very not well made. So that's my take on it.


	TheTwelfthRocket Dec 11 2015, 10:53 PM
Quote (metroidmetroid on Aug 18 2008, 2:15 PM) and the levels are not edits! YEAH SURE


	TheTwelfthRocket Dec 20 2015, 5:12 AM
Quote (metroidmetroid on Apr 17 2010, 2:26 AM) If you hate it so bad then way did you waste your time commenting? He's telling you it sucks. You never understand l:L


	TheTwelfthRocket Dec 20 2015, 6:14 AM
Quote (smbmaster99) i like this game a lot Quote (DoctorWario on Aug 18 2008, 1:05 AM) nice game https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qDfF2eeAwt4


	Cap'n Coconuts Dec 22 2015, 12:38 AM
You do realize that discussion happened half a decade ago, don't you?


	TheTwelfthRocket Jan 1 2016, 9:26 PM
Quote (Cap'n Coconuts on Dec 22 2015, 12:38 AM) You do realize that discussion happened half a decade ago, don't you? Yes. :)


	SMBXfan Oct 23 2016, 1:09 PM
A new review is out. Great.

Pages: (1) 1 | Last Unread