Review Information
Game Reviewed Mini Game Compil 3, by OmegaBowser
Review Author AsteriskX
Created Sep 24 2014, 5:59 AM

General Commentary and Game Overview
Minigame Compil 3 was a really good game, and with the trophies, medals and minigames to unlock, as well as the competitive online score made this pretty in to play! I have made many opinions, and you might to. This is the third time I've edited this review, but each time I've rated it higher! I bet you'll like this game, even if you don't like it that most at first.
 
Pros +The sound
+The minigames
+The gameplay
+Online, competitive scores!
+Hardly any glitchy-ness.
 
Cons -Mario, Luigi and all those Nintendo favorites should probably appear a little more often.
 
Impressions
Gameplay
7 / 10
The Gameplay differed, depending on the minigame, but as of controls, it was great! Most of the minigames were really cool, and overall the gameplay was a success.
 
Graphics
7 / 10
Most of the graphics were good, just like the menus, for example. Most of the graphics fit, and it is a unique kind of style depending on the minigame. A success, too.
 
Sound
7 / 10
The sound was pretty good. Not much to say about it, because the music is what you'd expect it to be, depending on which Minigame you examine. Pretty good, too.
 
Replay
7 / 10
Replay? Great! Online competitive high scores, things to unlock like minigames, trophies, and medals, and good minigames make the other scores alike.
 
Final Words
7 / 10
Many minigames to play, you can win medals, and much more. It's an above average game!

Comments
User Icon
EvilYoshiToes
Oct 3 2014, 12:28 AM
This review is... very harsh. Also, nobody ever said this was a game about Mario. So, therefore, complaining about Mario not showing up in a lot of the minigames doesn't make much sense.
Also, saying there are no pros to this game is most certainly untrue no matter how you look at this game. The graphics are really nice, especially in the menus. Also, what do you have against the sounds? I didn't find them to be bad at all, and you really didn't explain yourself. I also don't see what you have against the graphics, especially in the Test Your Might minigame.

I know this review is just your opinion, but for a fangame I actually thought this was very good...

Oh yes, and you should keep in mind that this is a fangame made for enjoyment. It's not going to be as good as an official game.
 
User Icon
AsteriskX
Oct 3 2014, 2:37 AM
Quote (EvilYoshiMan on Oct 3 2014, 12:28 AM)
This review is... very harsh. Also, nobody ever said this was a game about Mario. So, therefore, complaining about Mario not showing up in a lot of the minigames doesn't make much sense.
Also, saying there are no pros to this game is most certainly untrue no matter how you look at this game. The graphics are really nice, especially in the menus. Also, what do you have against the sounds? I didn't find them to be bad at all, and you really didn't explain yourself. I also don't see what you have against the graphics, especially in the Test Your Might minigame.

I know this review is just your opinion, but for a fangame I actually thought this was very good...

Oh yes, and you should keep in mind that this is a fangame made for enjoyment. It's not going to be as good as an official game.

Yes, I know. Fangames are not as good. When I submitted this, I looked back and regreted certain things. I was just showing my honest opinions and I will change the review. In fact, I sent something to the queue a while ago, so be expecting a change.
Sorry if you thought this was to harsh, I just did not see anything so good about it at the time.
Forgive me.
 
User Icon
AsteriskX
Oct 3 2014, 3:09 AM
Quote (EvilYoshiMan on Oct 3 2014, 12:28 AM)
This review is... very harsh. Also, nobody ever said this was a game about Mario. So, therefore, complaining about Mario not showing up in a lot of the minigames doesn't make much sense.
Also, saying there are no pros to this game is most certainly untrue no matter how you look at this game. The graphics are really nice, especially in the menus. Also, what do you have against the sounds? I didn't find them to be bad at all, and you really didn't explain yourself. I also don't see what you have against the graphics, especially in the Test Your Might minigame.

I know this review is just your opinion, but for a fangame I actually thought this was very good...

Oh yes, and you should keep in mind that this is a fangame made for enjoyment. It's not going to be as good as an official game.

I rated it a five, which means I'm ambivalent to it. While there were some ok things, I didn't find anything particularly cool about it. And if someone submits a review, they should give their honest opinions, am I right? Sorry you didn't enjoy it, it's just my opinion. I mean, I can't lie on the scores or what I think about it, right? Maybe you think I should've said it differently, and that's fine. Everyone tends to have a different way of saying things, and in your opinion, I may be more of a critic, unfortunately.

Sorry. Maybe I'll improve it, if I find something I should.
 
User Icon
Mors
Oct 3 2014, 11:47 AM
Wow. I was expecting 9 or 10 instead of 5.
 
User Icon
DJ Coco
Oct 3 2014, 7:18 PM
Reviews are subjective by nature, but I think you should be going for an objective stance. Being able to mention nothing positive about the game seems like a severe exaggeration even if you didn't like it. A 5/10 is a "just barely passed the test" in my opinion, and I think this game offers way more than that. But that's just my 2 cents on the matter, I'm not trying to say you should change the review.
 
User Icon
AsteriskX
Oct 3 2014, 7:20 PM
Quote (DJ Coco on Oct 3 2014, 7:18 PM)
Reviews are subjective by nature, but I think you should be going for an objective stance. Being able to mention nothing positive about the game seems like a severe exaggeration even if you didn't like it. A 5/10 is a "just barely passed the test" in my opinion, and I think this game offers way more than that. But that's just my 2 cents on the matter, I'm not trying to say you should change the review.

Thanks for the advice, DJ coco. Maybe I'll improve it.
 
No Icon
Willsaber
Oct 4 2014, 9:06 PM
I think there should be a lot more credit for the gameplay's merits, but he does have a point. Mainsite games should be expected to have more of a focus than Message Board games. :/
 
User Icon
Ryan Silberman
Oct 5 2014, 1:54 AM
This review really feels like it's repeatedly hammering down that there's only three Mario minigames instead of going deep into detail on why the minigames aren't good.
 
Pages: (1) 1 | Last Unread